Personal Finance Bloggers’ 2010 Stock Picking Contest Results (Q3)

A few personal finance bloggers decided to have a friendly stock picking contest for 2009 and we decided to do it again for 2010. We had made our picks back in December of 2009 and the plan was to track the calendar year performance of four picks (equal weighted for the sake of determining portfolio performance). As alluded to in my post that discussed my picks initially – don’t take these contests too seriously. A one year horizon is nothing more than gambling.

This year I decided to pick stocks at random, something akin to seeing how throwing darts at a newspaper would work. But seeing as how I don’t have darts, and I read my newspapers online, that method would’ve been a recipe for disaster as I just bought a new monitor. Instead, I picked some three letter words at random and then found the ticker symbols to match those words and that was basically it! Here were the words I picked:

FUN, HAT, ADD, CAR – I like to have FUN, when it’s cold I’ll wear a HAT, I sometimes have to ADD at work and I’m definitely a CAR guy.

And here are the corresponding companies:

1. Cedar Fair L.P. (FUN:NYSE) Stock price as of December 31st, 2009 (close): 11.41 and after Q3: 13.25 plus three quarterly dividend payments of $0.25. YTD Performance = +22.70%.

2. Hathor Exploration Limited (HAT:TSX-V) Stock price as of December 31st, 2009 (close): 1.81 and after Q3: 1.73. YTD Performance = -4.42%

3. Arctic Star Diamond Corp. (ADD:TSX-V) Stock price as of December 31st, 2009 (close): 0.055 and after Q3: 0.05. YTD Performance = -9.09%

4. AVIS Budget Group (CAR:NYSE) Stock Price as of December 31st, 2009 (close): 13.12 and after Q3: 11.65. YTD Performance = -11.20%

So on an equal weighted basis the picks are down 0.50% as a group. This keeps  me in the top half out of 9 participants so far in the contest. Not bad considering the whole 7 seconds I took to pick my stocks, but we still have one more quarter to go!

Here are the other bloggers’ results so far:

Here are links to the other guys. Not everyone has updated their blogs with their commentary yet, and if that’s the case  I will simply link to their homepage. Enjoy!

1. Dividend Growth Investor +21.34%

2. The Wild Investor +8.35%

3. Zach Stocks +0.84%

4. WhereDoesAllMyMoneyGo.com -0.50%

5. My Traders Journal -1.31%

6. Intelligent Speculator -7.86%

7. Million Dollar Journey -10.46%

8. The Financial Blogger -15.24%

9. Money Smarts Blog -27.07%

Preet Banerjee
Preet Banerjee
...is an independent consultant to the financial services industry and a personal finance commentator. You can learn more about Preet at his personal website and you can click here to follow him on Twitter.
Related Posts
Showing 6 comments
  • Sean

    So which ‘number” is an index say TSX 60?

    • Preet

      Hi Sean, sorry I don’t understand your question – could you elaborate?

pingbacks / trackbacks